Have you ever gone to a movie that everyone was saying was the best movie ever, but when you saw it, you thought it was only ok. It had some good parts. Maybe one or two good one-liners, but it didn’t live up to the hype. That ok movie is Jermichael Finley’s career so far.
Finley is entering into his fourth season. This year isn’t a make or break for him, but he has yet to play all 16 games in the regular season. If he doesn’t play in every single game, he will get the dreaded injured prone tag to his name.
There is no doubt he is highly talented, but what good is all his talent when he is injured on the sideline?
People are making him seem like the greatest tight end in the league, but I don’t even think he’s the best tight end from the 2008 draft.
John Carlson of the Seattle Seahawks has had a far better career than Finley. Both Carlson and Finley average 32 yards per game. Both of them average more than ten yards per catch and around five yards after the catch. Carlson has nearly five hundred more receiving yards in his career than Finley and almost twice as many touchdowns.
This is due to the fact that Carlson is more durable than Finley. Since they were drafted in 2008, Carlson has only missed five games compared to Finley’s sixteen games.
Finley has had flashes of greatness in between his trips to the inactive list. Until he can go a whole season without getting hurt, I don’t see how people can get lost in his hype. The local media and die-hard Packers fans make it sound like he is a first ballot hall-of-famer, when he hasn’t even made a pro bowl yet.
I root for Finley, but some people need to take off their green and gold blinders and look at the facts. In his one decent year, back in 2009, he only ranked in the top ten among tight ends in one category—receiving yards—and he was ranked tenth. That year he was twelfth among tight ends in receptions and fourteenth in touchdowns.
 |
| ESPN's Top 10 Tight End Rankings |
Before people make Finley King of the Tight Ends, shouldn’t he at least finish among the league leaders in receiving yards, receptions, and touchdowns? Or maybe just top five in one of those categories?
I know people say that he creates mismatches, but how valuable are those mismatches? The Packers went 3-2 in games that Finely played in last season. In games he didn’t play, they went 11-4, including the playoffs and a Super Bowl victory.
Is Jermichael Finley overrated? Not Yet. Is he over hyped? Definitely.